Family Disputes Over Property in Pakistan: Laws, Rights, and Resolution Options

Family disputes regarding property inheritance are common in Pakistan, especially among siblings (brothers and sisters). These disputes usually arise due to disagreements over ancestral property, unequal distribution, hidden transfers, or intentional exclusion from inheritance. Understanding the legal framework, rights of heirs, and available resolution options is essential to addressing these conflicts.

---

1. Understanding Property Inheritance Laws in Pakistan

Inheritance in Pakistan is governed primarily by Islamic law (Sharia), the Constitution of Pakistan, and various property laws. The key legal frameworks include:

• The Muslim Personal Law (Shariat) Application Act, 1937
• The West Pakistan Muslim Personal Law (Shariat) Act, 1962
• The Succession Act, 1925
• The Transfer of Property Act, 1882
• The Land Revenue Act, 1967

Ancestral vs. Self-Acquired Property

• Ancestral Property: Property inherited through generations, where ownership rights are automatically transferred to legal heirs upon the death of a property owner.
• Self-Acquired Property: Property legally acquired by an individual through purchase, gift, or other means, and can be distributed at the owner's discretion through a will.

---

2. Share of Brothers and Sisters in Inherited Property

In Pakistan, inheritance laws are primarily based on Islamic principles, which dictate the shares of legal heirs.

Shares as per Islamic Law

1. Son's Share: Sons inherit double the share of daughters in ancestral property.
2. Daughter's Share: Daughters receive half of what a son gets. However, they have the full right to claim it.
3. Mother’s Share: The mother is entitled to 1/6th of the property if children are present.
4. Father’s Share: The father also gets 1/6th of the property if children are present.
5. Widow’s Share: A widow receives 1/8th if there are children and 1/4th if there are no children.
6. Widower’s Share: A widower receives 1/4th if there are children and 1/2 if there are no children.

Can Sisters Be Denied Their Share?

• Legally, NO. Under Islamic law and Pakistani law, sisters cannot be denied their rightful inheritance.
• Socially and culturally, YES. In many cases, daughters and sisters are either pressured to give up their share or denied property by their male relatives.
• If a sister willingly gives up her share, it must be done legally through a written agreement or relinquishment deed.

---

3. Common Causes of Family Disputes Over Property

1. Unlawful Transfer of Property: Often, male heirs transfer ancestral property to their names without informing female heirs.
2. Forcing Sisters to Give Up Share: Daughters are pressured into giving up their share in favor of brothers.
3. Lack of Property Documentation: When property ownership records are not clear, disputes arise.
4. Second Marriages & Step-Siblings Conflicts: If the deceased had multiple wives or step-children, disputes over property division are common.
5. Hidden Sale or Fraudulent Mutation: Sometimes, properties are sold without informing all heirs.
6. Disputes Over Agricultural Land vs. Residential Property: Agricultural land has different inheritance rules under local customs, causing conflicts.
7. Will or Gift (Hiba) Disputes: If a parent distributes property through a gift (Hiba), some heirs may contest its validity.

---

4. How to Solve Property Disputes in Pakistan?

A. Legal Solutions

1. Filing a Suit for Partition in Civil Court

   • Any heir can file a partition suit under the Civil Procedure Code (CPC), 1908.
   • The court appoints a revenue officer to distribute property according to legal shares.
   • If property is indivisible, it may be auctioned and proceeds divided.

2. Filing an Inheritance Suit

   • If an heir is denied their share, they can file a suit for declaration of inheritance rights.
   • Under the Succession Act, 1925, courts can issue Succession Certificates for moveable assets like bank accounts, pensions, or business shares.

3. Challenging Illegal Transfer (Benami Transaction)

   • If a property is fraudulently transferred, heirs can challenge it under the Benami Transactions (Prohibition) Act, 2017.

4. Filing a Stay Order Against Property Sale

   • If one sibling tries to sell the property without agreement from all heirs, others can seek a stay order from the court to stop the transaction.

B. Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR)

1. Family Mediation and Reconciliation

   • Elders of the family or religious scholars can help resolve disputes without legal action.
   • Jirga or Panchayat (in rural areas) often intervene to settle disputes.

2. Mediation Through Lawyers

   • Lawyers can mediate and draft a legal settlement agreement between disputing parties.

3. Arbitration Through Local Authorities

   • Local government or Union Council officials may help resolve conflicts before court intervention.

---

5. How Strict is the Law?

• Inheritance laws in Pakistan are clear, but enforcement is weak due to social pressures, corruption, and lengthy legal procedures.
• Many women face difficulty claiming their inheritance despite legal rights.
• Property cases take years in courts, and legal expenses discourage rightful heirs from filing cases.
• Courts favor written documentation, so verbal agreements hold little legal value.

Challenges in Implementing the Law

• Male Dominance in Property Matters: In many families, men control property distribution.
• Forged Documents & Corruption: Some heirs create fake property transfers to cheat siblings.
• Delays in Court Cases: Inheritance disputes can take 5-10 years to resolve.
• Limited Awareness Among Women: Many women do not claim their inheritance due to a lack of knowledge or social pressure.

---

6. How Can a Fair Solution Be Ensured?

1. Clear Documentation: Register all property in a legal way and ensure names of all heirs are included.
2. Legal Will & Gift Deed (Hiba): If a parent wants to distribute property before death, they should do so legally and fairly.
3. Timely Property Division: Families should settle inheritance soon after the death of the original owner to avoid future disputes.
4. Legal Awareness Campaigns: Women and weaker heirs should be educated about their rights.
5. Government & Court Reforms: The judicial system should fast-track inheritance cases and penalize fraudulent property transfers.

Property disputes among brothers and sisters in Pakistan are complex and emotionally charged. Although Islamic and Pakistani laws clearly define inheritance rights, social customs, legal loopholes, and corruption make enforcement difficult. The best approach to resolving such disputes is early documentation, family mediation, and legal action if necessary.

While the law exists, strict enforcement and social awareness are needed to ensure justice for all heirs. Families should aim for fair, transparent, and timely property distribution to avoid long-term conflicts and ensure peace among siblings.